Firewalls
Ratings and Reviews of Personal Firewalls and Security Suites |
Firewalls and Security Suites
Firewall
software
is your
first line
of defense
from
attacks by
outside
agents -
be they
people or
software
programs.
Although
many
broadband
service
providers
offer "firewalled"
connections
and many
(if not
all)
broadband
routers
(see our
reviews on
Ethernet,
Phoneline
and
Powerline
and
Wi-Fi Home
Networks
for
further
information)
also
deliver
some
degree of
firewalling
and even
Windows XP
includes
firewall
software,
we still
recommend
that you
look into,
if not
definitely
purchase
one of the
firewall
software
packages
detailed
below.
Why?
For a few
reasons
(that are
worth the
dollars
you'll
spend on
this
software
type).
-
Many, if
not most
of these
packages
also
include
"extras"
beyond
intrusion
prevention
such as
pop-up
stoppers,
spyware
removers,
content
control
(parental
control
and
inappropriate
content
management),
reporting
(letting
you know
the IP
address
or other
information
of
attempted
intrusions
so you
can, if
you
wish,
report
the
information
to your
ISP -
Internet
Service
Provider,
for
further
action),
privacy
control
(blocking
cookies)
and
more.
-
You'll
get more
"control"
over the
security
of your
systems.
Especially
for
those of
you out
there
that
love to
get the
most out
of
technology
(and are
willing
to spend
the time
and
effort
to do
it),
most
firewall
software
gives
users a
way to
manage
the
security
of their
systems
as well
as
optimize
security
settings
for
their
specific
needs.
-
Most of
these
packages
include
"subscriptions"
that
either
on an
automated
or
manual
basis,
help you
to keep
abreast
of new
attack
methodologies.
The
software
either
updates
itself,
or the
company
allows
you to
access
their
web site
to
download
the
updates.
So, if
we've
convinced
you to go
further
and think
about
purchasing
firewall
software,
some
things to
think
about...
-
Compatibility
-
interestingly
enough,
the
biggest
complaint
I've
heard
about
firewall
software
is that
some
packages
tend to
"hang"
the PC
or shut
down the
Internet
connection
from
time-to-time.
You
should
check
the
vendors
technical
FAQ to
see if
they
have any
mention
of this
issue
(especially
for your
particular
operating
system).
Postings
are a
sure
"danger"
sign.
-
Extras -
as
noted
above,
the more
features
and
functions
included,
the less
you'll
have to
worry
about
- both
from a
security
and
software
compatibility
standpoint.
So, if
you can
get a
firewall
with
anti-pop-up
software
in it,
you
won't
have to
purchase
a
firewall
and
anti-pop-up
software
and
worry
about
whether
they'll
work
together
or not
(or
crash
your
machine!).
-
Reporting
-
it's
actually
very
surprising
how many
attacks
are
arriving
at "your
door"
every
day.
Reporting
is nice
sometimes
just to
assure
yourself
of the
effectiveness
of your
investment!
-
Applications
- some
communications
software
and
other
applications
(especially
network-based
ones)
are
"troubled"
by
firewalls.
In other
words,
they
just
can't
get
through!
Make
sure
BEFORE
you
implement
firewall
software
that,
especially
network-based
applications,
are
"firewall
friendly".

Ready to
upgrade
your
system's
protection?
Read on.
Some
manufacturers
offer more
than one
package in
this
category.
We'll
review
them in
table
format
within
that
manufacturer's
detailed
review.

Firewall and Security Suite Review
Personal
Firewalls*
(Rankings
- best, 5
symbols,
worst, 1
symbol)
|
Company |
Best
For* |
Simple Start-Up |
Cost |
Time Savings |
Ease of Use |
Works With |
Support |
Features
|
Overall
Rating |
|
Armor2net
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Ashampoo |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%1/2+ |
|
BitDefender
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Boomerang
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Broderbund
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%1/2 |
|
CA
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2+ |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Cosmi
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%1/2+ |
|
eAcceleration
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iiii1/2 |
%%%% |
|
F-Secure |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iiii+ |
%%%% |
|
Grisoft |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
IBM
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Intego
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Iolo |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Kaspersky
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
McAfee
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
Norman
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Novatix
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Panda Software
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%1/2+ |
|
PC Security Shield
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2+ |
iiii+ |
%%%%+ |
|
Sphinx Software
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹
|
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Sunbelt Software
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹
|
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Symantec
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Trend Micro
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Webroot
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%
% |
|
Zone Labs
|
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2+ |
iiii |
%%%
% |
* A =
Amateur,
R =
Rookie,
P =
Pro
Armor2net
Simple Start-Up
-
¹¹¹¹
Armor2net's
Personal
Firewall
is easy to
install
and use.
Cost
-
$$$$1/2
Armor2net
Personal
Firewall
is priced
at $29.99.
|
Software |
Price |
O/S
Supported |
Overview |
Features |
Compatibility |
|
Personal
Firewall version 3.12 |
$29.99 |
Windows
98,
ME,
2000,
XP |
Personal
Firewall |
-
Intrusion
protection
-
Alerts
to
attempted
intrusions
-
Grant
or
deny
access
to
Internet
on
per-application
basis
-
Display
of
active
connections
-
Block
or
shut-off
unsafe
connections
-
Pop-up
stopper
-
Spyware
remover
|
|
Time Savings -
¹¹¹¹
If you've
ever had
an
intruder
"plant" a
worm or
other
destructive
software
on your
system or
had them
'takeover'
your CPU,
you'll
know that
firewall
software
is a
productivity
boost -
just in
PREVENTING
lost time
due to
data
destruction
and system
outages.
Ease of Use
-
@@@@
Armor2net's
user
interface
is
straight
forward
and easy
to
understand.

Works With
-
YYY
Armor2net
is
designed
for the
Windows
environment
only.
Support
-
ppp
Armor2net
offers an
online FAQ
and email
support
only.
Features
-
iii1/2
Armor2net
has some
nice
features.
We
especially
like the
pop-up
stopper
and
spyware
remover
that is
included
with the
intrusion
detection
and
management
system.
Overall
Rating -
%%%1/2
Armor2net
offers
good
functionality
at a VERY
good
price.
Our
biggest
concern
regarding
this
software
is
customer
support.
However,
if you're
a good
"techie"
this
"concern"
isn't a
big one.
Ashampoo
Simple Start-Up
-
¹¹¹¹
Ashampoo's security software is simple to install and set up for
use.
Cost
-
$$$$1/2
Firewall Pro is priced at $29.99, Security Pack 2 at $39.89 and Firewall is a free
download.
|
Software |
Price |
O/S
Supported |
Overview |
Features |
Compatibility |
|
Firewall Pro 1.14 |
$29.99 |
Windows 2000, XP |
Firewall |
-
Firewall
-
Easy Mode configuration assistant
-
Expert Mode
-
Learning Mode identifies programs that makes Internet
connects and lets user decide on whether to allow them access
-
Rules creation
-
Child protection
-
Traffic volume limiting
-
Block All panic button for emergencies
-
AutoStart Manager to identify and disable unwanted
auto-starting programs
-
System Processes Monitor
-
Internet Cleaner
-
File Wiper
-
IP Spam Blocker
-
Internet Accelerator
-
Online updates
-
Monitor local and LAN connections
-
Stealth Ports and Port Scan Blocking
-
Connection Log
-
Real-time Connection Analysis
-
Communications Statistics
|
|
|
Security Pack 2 |
$39.89 |
Windows 2000, XP |
Security Suite |
-
Ashampoo AntiSpyWare 2 protection against spyware, adware,
browser hijackers, tracking cookies, dialers, worms, key loggers,
Trojans and rootkits. Includes I year of free signature updates.
-
Ashampoo AntiVirus protection against viruses, worms,
trojans, and dialers, 1 year signature updates
-
Ashampoo FireWall PRO (as above)
-
Ashampoo Magical Security 2- provides military-grade
encryption for data on hard drives, CDs and DVDs. Fully integrated
into Windows Explorer.
|
|
|
Firewall 1.20 |
Free |
Windows 2000, XP |
Firewall |
-
Firewall
-
Easy and Expert Modes
-
Learning Mode to identify programs that attempt to make
Internet connections, allows user to determine whether or not to allow
connection
-
Rules creation
-
Block All Panic Button
-
Monitor Local and Lan Connections
-
Connection Log
|
|
Time Savings -
¹¹¹¹
If you've
ever had
an
intruder
"plant" a
worm or
other
destructive
software
on your
system or
had them
'takeover'
your CPU,
you'll
know that
firewall
software
is a
productivity
boost -
just in
PREVENTING
lost time
due to
data
destruction
and system
outages.
Ease of Use
-
@@@@
Ashampoo offers both "Easy" and "Expert" modes in their software
that lets you do as much or as little "configuration" work as you desire.

Works With
-
YYY
Ashampoo products are designed for the Windows environment.
Support
-
ppp
Ashampoo's web site includes a support database with fixes for
common problems. If you need more help, email is your only option.
Features
-
iiii
A number of standard and "nice to have" features -
"easy and expert" modes, parental controls traffic volume limiting, Internet
cleaner, file wiper, Spam blocker, Internet accelerator and logging and analysis
tools in Firewall Pro and a robust security "solution" that includes AntiSpyWare
2,
AntiVirus, FireWall PRO and Magical Security 2 products in Security Pack 2.
Overall
Rating -
%%%1/2+
Very competitively priced products with good
functionality.
BitDefender
Simple Start-Up
-
¹¹¹¹
BitDefender products are straight forward to install
and set up for use.
Cost
-
$$$$
BitDefender Internet Security 2008 is priced at $39.95, Total
Security 2008 at $59.95.
|
Software |
Price |
O/S
Supported |
Overview |
Features |
Compatibility |
|
BitDefender Internet Security 2008 |
$39.95, 1 user 1 year |
Windows 2000, XP,
Vista |
Security Suite |
- Real-time Anti-Virus Protection
- Proactive protection
- Anti-Rootkit
- Gamer Mode
- Privacy Protection, Anti-spyware
- Web Anti-Phishing
- Firewall Protection
- Wi-Fi Wireless Protection
- Protection form SPAM Email
- Email Anti-Phishing
- Parental Control
- Web Time Limiter
- Application Control
|
-
Microsoft Outlook, Microsoft
Outlook Express, Netscape, Pegasus, The Bat
-
Internet Explorer
|
|
BitDefender Total Security 2008 |
$59.95, 1 user 1 year |
Windows 2000, XP, Vista |
Security Suite |
- Real-time Anti-Virus Protection
- Proactive protection
- Anti-Rootkit
- Gamer Mode
- Privacy Protection, Anti-spyware
- Web Anti-Phishing
- Firewall Protection
- Wi-Fi Wireless Protection
- Protection form SPAM Email
- Email Anti-Phishing
- Parental Control
- Web Time Limiter
- Application Control
- Data Backup
- PC Tune-Up, Trace Clean-Up
|
-
Microsoft Outlook, Microsoft
Outlook Express, Netscape, Pegasus, The Bat
-
Internet Explorer
|
Time Savings -
¹¹¹¹
If you've
ever had
an
intruder
"plant" a
worm or
other
destructive
software
on your
system or
had them
'takeover'
your CPU,
you'll
know that
firewall
software
is a
productivity
boost -
just in
PREVENTING
lost time
due to
data
destruction
and system
outages. The addition of Anti-Virus and Anti-Spam capabilities makes this
package a huge help in protecting your critical business data.
Ease of Use
-
@@@@
BitDefender products include configuration wizards to
help you get started. Once in place, you probably won't even think about
the software (unless it detects an attack).
Works With
-
YYY1/2
BitDefender's main products are designed for the Windows
environment. They offer "free" anti-virus software for Linux and
FreeBSD
distributions.
Support
-
pppp
BitDefender's web site includes a searchable knowledge base, downloads, a FAQ
and user manuals. If you need more help, you can use BitDefender's online
live chat service to contact tech support. Live Chat is available 24/7.
Features
-
iiii
Solid anti-virus, anti-spam and firewall
software. Extra for anti-virus is scanning of file sharing and instant
messaging attachments as well as standard file and email scanning. Anti-rootkit
and anti-phishing capabilities are also plusses.
Overall
Rating -
%%%%
It's hard not to like these products.
Solid features and functions, competitive pricing and a good technical support
strategy. Definitely should be on your purchasing "short list".
Boomerang
Simple Start-Up
-
¹¹¹¹
Boomerang's
eXtendia
PC
Firewall
is easy to
install
and
set-up.
Cost
-
$$$$
eXtendia
PC
Firewall
is priced
at $29.95.
|
Software |
Price |
O/S
Supported |
Overview |
Features |
Compatibility |
|
eXtendia
PC
Firewall |
$29.95 |
Windows
98,
ME,
NT
4.0,
2000,
XP |
Personal
Firewall |
-
Controls
inbound
and
outbound
traffic
-
Intrusion
detection system
-
Security
Monitor
-
Parental
Control
-
Automatic
Warning Notification when programs attempt unauthorized Internet
connections
-
Creates
evidence logs of Internet activity by program
|
| |