IP Phones
Ratings and Reviews of IP Phones |
IP Phones
Now that you've decided to go complete to "IP" as your network
of choice - for data and voice, maybe it's time you dumped that old
analog telephone and migrated to a VoIP phone that can not only plug right into
your broadband router using Ethernet (10/100 or 10/100/100Mbps) instead of that
old RJ-11 phone jack. Not only is the connectivity much faster and easier,
a VoIP phone can also integrate with your data applications to do some "neat"
stuff like display your Outlook contact information on the display and much,
much more.
But, before you run out and purchase one of these slick
new phones there are a few things we think you should consider.
- Call Control - what systems and/or protocols does
the IP phone work with? If it's just with a specific vendors IP PBX
platform - you'll have to have that software/hardware for the phone to
function. If however, it supports SIP it may (as with any standard
SIP - Session Initiation Protocol - phones sometimes don't work quite as
expected - check to make sure it will work with your systems/equipment
before you buy!) work in an "open" IP telephony environment.
- Codec Support - the most common codecs (analog to
digital conversions) include:
- G.711 - 8 bit compressed pulse code modulation
sampled at the rate of 8,000 samples per second creating a 64Kbps
bitstream
- ADPCM - adaptive differential pulse-code modulation,
converts sound or analog information to a digital format
- G.729 Annex A - processes signals with 10ms frames
and has a 5ms look-ahead resulting in a total of 15ms algorithmic delay,
input/output is 16 bit linear PCM samples that are converted to 8Kbps
compressed data stream
- G.729 Annex B - provides a high level description of
the Voice Activity Detection (VAD), Discontinuous Transmission (DTX) and
Comfort Noise Generator (CNG) algorithms. The algorithms are designed
to reduce the transmission rate during period of silence during a
conversation.
- Connectivity - Power over Ethernet support is a
good thing (you won't need a separate power adapter!), and in addition to a
standard Ethernet (10/100 or Gigabit) connection, a connector for a headset
is a good thing as well.
-
Display -
An IP phone should have a readable display - why? Because at some
point you're going to find your voice and data applications coming together
and you'll want your phone to be able to display "extras" like contact
information and results from simple data queries.
-
Extras - As
with any phone, the "extras" can "make" the phone. Look for things
like message waiting indicators, feature keys, programmable buttons, fixed
feature buttons (for things like speaker, redial, conference, transfer,
hold, voice mail, etc.) and easy navigation arrows/wheels.

As always - price is
very important too! So make sure the phone you purchase meets the demands
of your pocket book as well.
That's about it! Let's take a look at the Voice over IP
phone options that are available to you. Detailed information is available
in our product matrix at
IP Phones.

IP Phones Review
"IP" Telephones"*
(Rankings - best, 5 symbols,
worst, 1 symbol)
|
Company |
Best For* |
Simple Start-Up |
Cost |
Time Savings |
Ease of Use |
Works With |
Support |
Features |
Overall Rating |
|
3Com
|
ARP |
นนน1/2 |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Alcatel |
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp |
iiii |
Inc. |
|
ArtDio |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Avaya |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Cisco |
ARP |
นนน1/2 |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp1/2 |
iiii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
ConairPhone
|
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii |
Inc. |
|
Creative |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
D-Link |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Freecom |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
GE |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Hawking
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
IO Gear
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$+ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii+ |
%%%1/2 |
|
Ipevo |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
i-rocks |
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pp1/2 |
iii |
Inc. |
|
Jaht |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Kensington |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Keyspan |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Koutech |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
ppp1/2
|
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Linksys |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
pppp1/2
|
iiii1/2 |
%%%%1/2 |
|
Logitech |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
pppp
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Motorola |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
|
pppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Nortel
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
|
pppp1/2
|
iiii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
Okion |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
ppp1/2
|
iii |
%%%1/2 |
|
ORtek |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
pp1/2
|
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Panasonic |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
pppp
|
iiii+ |
%%%%+ |
|
Polycom
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
pppp1/2+
|
iiii+ |
%%%%+ |
|
Samsung |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
ShoreTel
|
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
Inc. |
|
Siemens |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
pppp1/2
|
iiii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
SOYO |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Toshiba |
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
|
pppp
|
iiii |
Inc. |
|
TRENDnet |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY+
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Uniden
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
|
pppp
|
iiii |
%%%% |
|
USR |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY
1/2 |
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
VTech
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Zonet |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%
1/2+ |
|
Zultys |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp1/2 |
iiii+ |
%%%
% |
|
ZyXEL |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
* A =
Amateur, R =
Rookie, P =
Pro
3Com |