Local Voice
Ratings and Reviews of Local Voice Services |
Local Voice Thoughts
Local voice services, although simple in concept are complex
in implementation. A couple of things to remember before we start:
- Every state has its own regulatory body that watches over
telephone services within its borders (in addition to the Federal Government
through the FCC). Therefore, service providers operating in multiple
states will often provide not only different sets of services but also vastly
different pricing for the same services. Therefore, in our reviews,
we're looking more at the "macro" than the state level of service. To
make sure you can get some of the services we talk about - at some of the
prices we quote - check with your provider in your specific geography.
- There are hundreds of small operators that service many
rural areas in the U.S. We have not reviewed them (a simply overwhelming
task) frankly, because folks in those areas don't have a lot of choice.
It's the local provider or nothing. This may change in the future, but
not in the near term. So if you operate your business in an area where
there is a single provider, you'll have to make do with their service
offerings.
- We've reviewed service offerings of cable companies and
some other "non-incumbents". Most of them provide their services in
specific geographies only. Check with them to make sure their services
are available in your area before getting too far down the road.
- Finally, there are also a number of small CLECs
(Competitive Local Exchange Carriers) that service residential customers.
Many of these companies simply resell ILEC services, a few have their own
switching equipment. Again, any attempt to review all of those companies
at this time would be impossible (if you'd like us to look at someone
specific, however, let us know). With that said, many of these companies
provide competitive services at very good prices (here in McKinney, TX
we have Sage Telecom for example). It might be worth your time and good
for your pocketbook to check into their capabilities and pricing.
Last thought - remember that voice services remain the
"lifeline" of your business - and will often be one of the largest ongoing costs
your business must support. And although getting basic telephone services
often just seems like a "no brainer" the alternatives that are available - to
help you contain costs and implement innovative services that can help you and
your business be more productive - should make you think twice before just
"signing up" for standard POTS with your local ILEC.
Let's get to it. Our review of Local Voice Services and
Service Providers follows. (Note: If you don't recall our
rating system: Rating Guide.)

Local Voice Services Review
Local Voice Services and Service Providers*
(Rankings - best, 5 symbols,
worst, 1 symbol)
|
Company |
Best For* |
Simple Start-Up |
Cost |
Time Savings |
Ease of Use |
Works With |
Support |
Features |
Overall Rating |
|
allo.com |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYYY |
pppp+ |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
AT&T |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
CallWave |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Charter |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Comcast |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
ConnectMe |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
Cox |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Earthlink |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
EMBARQ |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii |
%%%% |
|
GotVMail |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
iConnectHere |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
IDT |
A,R,P |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Lingo |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Net2Phone |
ARP |
¹¹¹1/2 |
$$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹1/2 |
@@@1/2 |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Packet8 |
ARP |
¹¹¹1/2 |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp+ |
iii1/2+ |
%%%% |
|
Qwest |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
RingCentral |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp+ |
iiii+ |
%%%%+ |
|
Skype |
R,P |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
Time Warner Cable |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
Verizon |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Verizon/MCI |
ARP |
¹¹¹1/2 |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
ViaTalk |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$1/2 |
¹¹¹¹
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
Vonage |
R,P |
¹¹¹¹ |
$$$$ |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
Windstream |
ARP |
¹¹¹¹ |
INC. |
¹¹¹¹ |
@@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii |
INC. |
* A =
Amateur, R =
Rookie, P =
Pro
allo.com
Simple Start-Up
-
¹¹¹¹
allo.com
offers eight residential and business plans as well as "add-on" services that
are designed for business customers.
Cost -
$$$$
Pricing
for allo.com services is detailed below.
| VoIP Plans
- Residential |
Monthly |
Annual |
PAYG |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Monthly Charge |
$23.95 |
$199.00 per year for 2 years |
$0.00, credits starting at $10.00 (valid for 1 year) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Phone Number |
1 included |
1 included |
$7.95 per month |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Outgoing Calls (lines/channels) |
Unlimited, 1 |
Unlimited, 1 |
Pay per Minute, Unlimited |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Incoming Calls (lines/channels) |
Unlimited, 1 |
Unlimited, 1 |
Unlimited, 1 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Virtual Numbers |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
|
|
|
|
|
|
AlloFAX |
$9.95 per month, Unlimited Incoming/100
Minutes Outgoing |
$9.95 per month, Unlimited Incoming/100
Minutes Outgoing |
$9.95 per month, Unlimited Incoming/100
Minutes Outgoing |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Toll Free Number |
$4.00 per month, $39.00 per year |
$4.00 per month, $39.00 per year |
$4.00 per month, $39.00 per year |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Special Deal |
Free ATA or 2nd Month Free |
Buy/Lease ATA |
Buy ATA |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Transfer Existing Number |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
|
|
|
|
|
|
411 Directory Assistance |
Free |
Free |
Free |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Activation Fee |
None |
None |
None |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Business Plans |
SoHo |
Custom |
Lite |
Basic |
Elite |
|
|
|
|
Monthly Charge |
$39.00 |
$19.00 |
$79.00 |
$159.00 |
$299.00 |
|
|
|
|
Phone Number |
1 included |
1 included |
1 included |
2 included |
4 included |
|
|
|
|
Outgoing Calls (lines/channels) |
Unlimited, 1 |
Pay Per Minute, Unlimited |
6,000 minutes, Unlimited |
12,500 Minutes, Unlimited |
25,500 Minutes, Unlimited |
|
|
|
|
Incoming Calls (lines/channels) |
Unlimited, 1 |
Unlimited, 2 |
Unlimited, 2 |
Unlimited, 4 |
Unlimited, 8 |
|
|
|
|
Virtual Numbers |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
$4.95 per month |
|
|
|
|
AlloFAX |
Fax Number + Unlimited Incoming + 100 Minutes Outgoing Included |
Fax Number + Unlimited Incoming + 100 Minutes Outgoing Included |
Fax Number + Unlimited Incoming + 100 Minutes Outgoing Included |
Fax Number + Unlimited Incoming + 100 Minutes Outgoing Included |
Fax Number + Unlimited Incoming + 100 Minutes Outgoing Included |
|
|
|
|
Toll Free Number |
$2.00 monthly/ $19.00 per year |
1 Included |
1 Included |
1 Included |
1 Included |
|
|
|
|
Special Deal |
1 Free ATA |
Buy/Lease ATA |
1 Free ATA |
2 Free ATA's |
4 Free ATA's |
|
|
|
|
Transfer Existing Number |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
$9.99 one time transfer fee |
|
|
|
|
411 Directory Assistance |
$0.10 |
$0.10 |
$0.10 |
$0.10 |
$0.10 |
|
|
|
|
Activation Fee |
$29.00 |
None |
$29.00 |
$29.00 |
$29.00 |
|
|
|
|
Toll Free Numbers |
$10.00 |
$50.00 |
$250.00 |
$500.00 |
$1,000.00 |
$2,500.00 |
$5,000.00 |
|
|
Price Per Minute |
$0.035 |
$0.03 |
$0.025 |
$0.023 |
$0.021 |
$0.02 |
$0.019 |
|
|
Minutes Packages |
286 |
1,667 |
10,000 |
21,739 |
47,619 |
125,000 |
263,158 |
|
|
Local Minutes |
$10 |
$25 |
$50 |
$100 |
$250 |
$1,000 |
$2,500 |
$5,000 |
|
Price Per Minute |
$0.02 |
$0.018 |
$0.016 |
$0.014 |
$0.013 |
$0.012 |
$0.011 |
$0.0095 |
|
Minutes Packages |
500 |
1,389 |
3,125 |
7,143 |
19,231 |
83,333 |
227,273 |
526,315 |
|
International Credits |
$10 |
$25 |
$50 |
$100 |
|
|
|
|
|
Channels |
$9 per Channel |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time Savings -
¹¹¹¹
A
good communications package can help you save time and stay in touch with your
customers. allo.com's packages are designed to help you do that.
Ease of Use -
@@@@
allo.com's services can be managed via the web, and your analog phone works just
like it always did - with the help of an ATA.
Works With -
YYYYY
allo.com
services work with both the traditional PSTN and IP networks - and can also work
with any SIP-based phone, including newer cell phones with SIP clients.
Support -
pppp+The
technical support area of the allo.com web site includes a FAQ, details on VoIP,
installation support and information on number portability and more. If
you need help you can contact allo.com tech support via email, using their live
chat capability on the web site or at their "800" number.
Features - iiii
allo.com services include the ability to use their services "on
the road" (Mobile VoIP), voicemail, Caller ID with name, ID spoofing, a
softphone client, E-911 dialing, 411 assistance, call conferencing, call
forwarding, call waiting, international call block, in-networking calling, call
history/search, change phone number, simultaneous ring, area code selection and
the ability to use any SIP-based device on the all.com service network.
Overall Rating
- %%%%+
Competitively priced VoIP services for both the very small home
business (residential) and the more robust ones (business services). A
good support strategy is in place as well. But, make sure your broadband
service has enough bandwidth to ensure voice quality before you switch.
AT&T
Simple Start-Up -
¹¹¹¹
AT&T offers traditional local services as well as AT&T's CallVantage Voice
over IP services for home business owners with broadband Internet access.
Cost - $$$$
AT&T's local, bundled services are outlined below.
| |
Online Select |
|
Local Phone Service |
Yes |
|
Unlimited Nationwide Calling |
Yes |
|
Features |
Caller ID, Call Waiting, Call Waiting ID, Privacy Manager, Three-Way
Calling, Call Forwarding, Call Return, Call Blocker, Auto Redial, Speed
Calling 8, Priority Call, Selective Call Forwarding |
|
Price |
$40.00 per month, $13.95
activation fee |
| |
AT&T CallVantage Service Plan |
AT&T CallVantage Local Plan |
AT&T CallVantage 2-Line Plan |
|
Home phone line, local calling |
Unlimited Local |
Unlimited Local |
Unlimited Local |
|
Features |
Call log, Voicemail, Phone
Book, Locate Me, Do Not Disturb, Speed Dial, Conference Calling, 3-Way
Calling, Call Forwarding, Call Waiting, Caller ID, E-911 Service, Safe
Forward Number Fax and Modem Support, Directory Assistance |
Call log, Voicemail, Phone
Book, Locate Me, Do Not Disturb, Speed Dial, Conference Calling, 3-Way
Calling, Call Forwarding, Call Waiting, Caller ID, E-911 Service, Safe
Forward Number Fax and Modem Support, Directory Assistance |
Call log, Voicemail, Phone
Book, Locate Me, Do Not Disturb, Speed Dial, Conference Calling, 3-Way
Calling, Call Forwarding, Call Waiting, Caller ID, E-911 Service, Safe
Forward Number Fax and Modem Support, Directory Assistance, 2nd Line |
|
Long Distance |
Unlimited Domestic |
$.04 per minute |
Unlimited Long Distance |
|
Total Plan |
$24.99,
Service Activation Fee $29.99 |
$19.99, Service Activation
Fee $29.99 |
$49.99, Service Activation
Fee $29.99 |
Time Savings -
¹¹¹¹
You
can't do without a local voice service for your business (even if you do use
your cell phone more than your land line).
Ease of Use -
@@@@@
Is
there anything easier to use than the telephone?
Works With -
YYYYY
AT&T
gives you lots of options and they don't force you to use AT&T long distance
services (although if you do a lot of calling one of their packages with
unlimited long distance could save you a ton of money see our
Voice and Data Service Bundles Ratings and
Review for more information).
Support -
pppp
AT&T's web site includes the ability for
you to manage your account and personal information as well as get |