Privacy

Ratings and Reviews of Privacy and Content Control Software

 

Privacy and Content Control

You might be unaware that as you "surf" the web, you are not only leaving a "trail" (where you come from [IP address] where you've been, how you got there, what browser or operating system you use), but also are picking up "snippets" of code that stick to your system like a parasite sucking up your storage, CPU and memory resources as well as reporting back to any number of organizations and individuals your surfing habits and other data.  Scared yet? 

 

On top of that, any number of sites or individuals purveying inappropriate content  would just "love" to get their "products" in front of your or your children's eyes.  If you've ever made a mistake and typed in a URL that landed you at a site that you found "interesting" at best, or used a search engine to research a topic, clicked on a link and, again, found yourself confronted with an "interesting" screen, you know exactly what we're talking about. 

Privacy and content control software were designed to protect you from these latest "innovations" in web technology.  When we purchased our first anti-spyware software some months ago, and ran it on a couple of our PCs we were absolutely SHOCKED to see the number of spyware "snippets" it discovered as well as cookies that had been deposited on the hard drives.  We're frankly embarrassed to admit that the number was in the thousands (too much surfing for information!). We have also found content control good more for productivity than anything else.  If the site isn't one we'd REALLY be interested in, we just don't get there because our content control software blocks access. 

Obviously, privacy protection and content control are good things.  But now that you've decided you need the software, what should you look for before you buy?

  • Your software should block "unwanted" software parasites like cookies and ads.  It should also allow you to "clean up" and delete these parasites and other "undetected" spyware from your system
     
    Google
     
    Web Home Office Reports
  • Content filters should allow you to block web sites that contain inappropriate content yet have an easy-to-use override function - after all, maybe your brother-in-law does need some entertainment.CA Anti-Spyware 2007
  • Additionally, we believe there are other software security functions (and we've included some of them on this page) that you might need - permanently erasing files upon deletion (did you know that when you delete files, they really aren't gone???), password protection for your system, files or hard drive, encryption of data transferred over the Internet and more.  We've included some of these software products as well under the "privacy" banner. 

So, if you don't like that fact that web site you visit has learned something about you, that some of them have planted software "parasites" on your system or have been offended by content you regard as inappropriate - read on.

  Internet Cleanup

Some vendors offer more than one package in this category.  We'll review them in table format within that vendor's detailed review.

Privacy and Content Control Software Review

Privacy and Content Control Software*

(Rankings - best, 5 symbols, worst, 1 symbol)

Company Best For* Simple Start-Up Cost Time Savings Ease of Use Works With Support Features Overall Rating

Allume

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYYY

ppp

iii1/2+

%%%1/2+

Anonymizer

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@1/2

YYY1/2

ppp

iiii+

%%%%+

Ashampoo

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iiii

%%%%

Avanquest

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pp1/2

iii1/2+

%%%1/2+

Boomerang

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iii1/2

%%%1/2

Broderbund

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pp1/2

iii1/2+

%%%1/2

CA

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp1/2+

iii1/2

%%%1/2+

Cosmi

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YY1/2+

pp1/2

iii1/2

%%%

Detto

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YY1/2+

pp1/2

iii1/2

%%%

Enteractive

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iii1/2

%%%

FBM Software

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iii1/2

%%%1/2

Intego

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY1/2

ppp

iiii

%%%%

McAfee

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pppp1/2

iiii

%%%%

Neobyte Solutions

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iiii1/2

%%%%

Norman

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp1/2

iiii

%%%%

Panda Software

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp1/2

iii1/2

%%%1/2+

ParetoLogic

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp+

iii1/2

%%%1/2+

PC Security Shield

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp1/2+

iiii

%%%%

Spyware Nuker

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pp

iii

%%%

Sunbelt Software

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pp

iii

%%%

Symantec

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pppp

iiii

%%%%

Tenebril

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pppp

iii1/2+

%%%%

Trend Micro

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pppp1/2

iii1/2

%%%%

Webroot

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

pppp

iiii

%%%%

X-Block

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$1/2

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp

iii1/2

%%%1/2

ZoneLabs

ARP

¹¹¹¹

$$$$

¹¹¹¹

@@@@

YYY

ppp1/2+

iiii+

%%%%

* A = Amateur, R = Rookie, P = Pro

 

 

Allume (Recently acquired by Smith Micro)           

Click Here to Buy Internet Cleanup For Windows!

Simple Start-Up - ¹¹¹¹

Allume's software is easy to install and set-up for initial use.

Cost - $$$$

Internet Cleanup (Windows and Macintosh versions) is priced at $29.99 (upgrade is $14.99).

Software Price O/S Supported Overview Features Compatibility

Internet Cleanup 5.0 for Windows, 4.0 for Macintosh

$29.99, upgrade $14.99

Windows  2000, XP

Macintosh OS 9.1 to OS X 10.1.5 or later

Privacy Software
  • IC Spyware detects and removes spyware, adware, trojan horses, browser hijackers, dialers, cookies and keyloggers

  • Personal information protector

  • SpamCather spam protection

  • Filesystem Guard prevents other users from viewing or altering personal files, histories or settings

  • Password Protector

  • Quickfill completes web forms and logins

  • Netblockade ad and pop-up blocking

  • Scheduler for routine cleanup tasks such as purging cache files or deleting history logs

  • Fastclean cleans browser cache, cookies, histories, ActiveX and plug-ins

  • Remote Cleanup cleans all PCs on your network form one system

  • Secure Delete file shredding

  • Automatic updates

 

Time Savings - ¹¹¹¹

Allume's privacy software  will help plug the gaps that intruders or inappropriate content can exploit - saving you time and money!

Ease of Use - @@@@

Internet Cleanup is simple to customize for your specific privacy requirements.

Internet Cleanup 5.0 WinWorks With - YYYY

Allume makes privacy software for both the Windows and Macintosh environments.

Support - ppp

Allume offers a FAQ and knowledge base.  If you need more help, you must use their online tech support forum and hope that their folks respond to your questions quickly.

Features - iii1/2+

Pretty basic privacy functionality - removal of spyware and cache and cookie clean-up.  Useful, basic software capabilities.

Overall Rating - %%%1/2+

Basic software at a competitive price.  Costs are low for the software through limited tech support, so just remember that before you purchase the software if tech support is important to you (in other words if you sometimes struggle with your system or implementing new software on it).

 

Anonymizer

Simple Start-Up - ¹¹¹¹

Anonymizer's software and software/service combinations are all simple to install and customize to meet your privacy needs.

Cost - $$$$

Total Net Shield is priced at $99.95 for one year, $179.95 for two years, Anti-Spyware $29.95 for one year, $49.95 for two years, Digital Shredder Lite at $4.99 for one year $6.99 for two years,  Anonymous Surfing is $29.99 for one year, $49.99 for two years, Anonymizer Dialup is $199.98 per year ($16.67 per month), Nyms is $19.99 for one year, $29.99 for two years, Safe Surfing Suite is $49.99 for one year and $69.99 for two years and Safe Surfing Professional is $119.99 for one year, $199.99 for two years.

Software Price O/S Supported Overview Features Compatibility
Total Net Shield $99.95 per year, $179.95 for two years Any Internet connected computer, Toolbar requires Windows OS and Explorer 6.0

Privacy Service

  • Secure tunneling (SSH) service and software encrypting all transmissions from the protected system
  • Includes Private Surfing capabilities
  • Secure and private email account (send mail anonymously)
  • Secure and private newsgroup access
  • SpamAssassin Anti-Spam service
  • Secure and Private instant messaging and chat
  • Filter and block cookies, banner ads and tracking bugs

Internet Explorer 6.0 for Privacy Toolbar

Anti-Spyware $29.95 per year, two years $49.95 Windows 2000, XP, Vista

Spyware Software

  • Removes malicious applications including spyware, key loggers and browser hijackers
  • Removes adware
  • Automatic updates
  • Scheduling
  • Customizable - create list of known sites to prevent removal of trusted programs or list of harmful programs to remove automatically
 
Digital Shredder Lite $4.99 for one year, $6.99 for two years Windows 2000, XP, Vista

Privacy Software

  • Erases cookies, cache files and history archives
  • Uses military-grade file deletion
  • Runs automatically when system is shut down
  • Customizable security levels
 
Safe Surfing Suite $49.99 for one year, $69.99 for two years Windows 2000, XP, Vista Privacy Software and Service
  • Anonymous Surfing - online privacy
  • Anonymizer Anti-Spyware- spyware removal
  • Anonymizer Digital Shredder Lite - erases cookies, cache files and history archives
  • Anonymizer Nyms - protects primary email address and identity with disposable anonymous email addresses
 
Safe Surfing Professional $119.99 for one year, $199.99 for two years Windows 2000, XP, Vista Privacy Software and Service
  • Total NetShield - encryption, anonymous surfing and anti-spam
  • Anonymizer Anti-Spyware- spyware removal
  • Anonymizer Digital Shredder Lite - erases cookies, cache files and history archives
  • Anonymizer Nyms - protects primary email address and identity with disposable anonymous email addresses
 

 

Anonymous Surfing $29.99 for one year, $49.99 for two years Windows 2000, XP, Vista Privacy Software and Service
  • Keeps IP address unlisted
  • Secures data sent over wireless connections
  • Starts automatically, runs in background
  • 128-bit SSL technology
  • Redirects web traffic through Anonymizer secure servers to hide identity
  • Includes free Digital Shredder for safe file deletion
 
Anonymizer Dialup Plus Total Net Shield $199.99 per year Windows Dial Internet Access Service with Privacy Control
  • Includes 200 hours per month of connection time
  • Includes Total Net Shield
  • Secure tunneling
  • Custom Anonymizer SSH tunneling software
 
Nyms $19.99 for one year, $29.99 for two years Windows 2000, XP, Vista Privacy Software
  • Provides disposable, anonymous email addresses for online activities
  • Protects personal email address
  • Keeps inbox free of spam
  • Create guest accounts for friends
 

Time Savings - ¹¹¹¹

Anonymizer's privacy services and software  will help plug the gaps that intruders or inappropriate content can exploit - saving you time and money!

Ease of Use - @@@@1/2

Anonymizer's Privacy Toolbar makes it easy to customize the service to meet your specific "privacy" needs.  And, as Anonymizer delivers 99% service (not desktop software), you won't be faced with as many compatibility and system performance issues as with a software only solution.  All of the Anonymizer solutions are simple to setup and use.  And, once you have them in place, you probably won't have to "tweak" them much, they'll just be there - protecting your system and your data.

Get Total Net Shield direct from Anonymizer!Works With - YYY1/2

Although the service "works" with any Internet-connected system, you'll need Windows and Explorer 6.0 for the Privacy Toolbar and any service customization to function.

Support - ppp

Anonymizer offers a useful FAQ, but if you run into any problems that can't be answered there, email is your only option.  This is a somewhat questionable strategy for a "service" rather than "software" provider.

Features - iiii+

We especially like the Total Net Shield Service that "privatizes"  Email, Chat, Instant Messaging and Newsgroup data, Nyms that provides disposable email addresses for online use, as well as the I.D. Protection Suite that combines Anonymizer services with ZoneAlarm firewall software.  However, Anonymizer offers a comprehensive software privacy product line-up that is unequaled and, that probably includes as much - or as little protection as you'll need. 

Overall Rating - %%%%+

We often struggle with the service versus software question.  If you purchase the service, you pay every year, year after year.  However, as security software companies now have begun charging a yearly "subscription" price for virus and privacy updates, the yearly cost - service versus software and subscription - is just about equal.  So, Anonymizer's service approach is as good, if not better, than most software implementations.  Our biggest complaint about the Anonymizer privacy services is their lack of any customer contact capability beyond email.  If the service is out, and you can't send them an email.........

 

Ashampoo

Simple Start-Up - ¹¹¹¹

Ashampoo's Magical Security products are simple to download and install on your system.

Cost - $$$$

Magical Security is priced at $19.99, Magical Security 2.0 is $29.99.

Software Price O/S Supported Overview Features Compatibility

Magical Security version 1.70

$19.99

Windows 98, ME, 2000, XP

Drive Encryption Software

  • Decrypt and encrypt files with a click of the mouse

  • Wipe file permanently from hard disk

  • Encrypt and burn encrypted files directly to CD or DVD

  • Encrypt files to self-extracting EXE archive

  • Encrypt and burn EXE archives directly to CD or DVD

  • File manager

  • AES encryption support

 
 Magical Security 2.0 $29.99 Windows 2000, XP, Vista Drive Encryption Software
  • Decoding and encoding of files with one click
  • Complete deletion of files
  • Integration with Windows Explorer
  • Burn onto CD and DVD
  • Encoding and burning in a single step
  • Encoding and email dispatch in single step
  • Encoding files to .EXE archives and burning them to CD or DVD
  • Encoding of files to self extracting archives for email dispatch
  • Integrated file manager
  • Compression of encoded files

Time Savings - ¹¹¹¹

If you share a hard drive or have information on it that MUST remain private, Ashampoo's Magical Security products are great utilities to encrypt data as well as store encrypted data (back it up!) on CD or DVD.  Real time savers that are simple to use.

Ease of Use - @