Wi-Fi Equip.
Ratings and Reviews of Wi-Fi Networking Equipment |
Wireless Networking
Wireless is "hot" - whether for your "traveling" needs (see
our
Wi-Fi Services Ratings and Review for more
information) or for your home. With that in mind, we believe there a few
things to consider before making that equipment choice:
- Again, Speed - are you going to go with 802.11b (11
Mbps) or 802.11g (54 Mbps) or MIMO technology (dual antennas) that can reach
108Mbps for your network or even 802.11n that is designed to reach 200Mbps
(of course the slower the cheaper, the faster the more expensive)...
- Interference - it's important that before you
purchase and implement your network that you consider possible sources of
interference (if you don't, network performance will suffer and you'll be
very unhappy!). Physical sources of interference include:
- Windows in brick wall - 2dB
- Metal frame, glass wall into building - 6dB
- Office wall - 6dB
- Metal door in office wall - 6dB
- Cinder wall - 4dB
- Metal door in brick wall - 12.4dB
- Brick wall next to metal door - 3dB
And, if you have a 2.4
GHz cordless phone, you may have to change the channel of the phone (you'll see
serious performance issues on your wireless network if this is a problem!).
If your phone can't change channels, you'll have to change the channel on the
access point. Most of the vendors can help you with this.
-
Access Points and
Signal Boosters, Adapters Too! - Simply put, if you're going to connect
your home wireless network to the Internet through a broadband cable modem or
DSL connection, you'll need a wireless access point that not only serves as the
"hub connection" for your devices but also as a router (basically a router
provides a path from each PC - on your network - to the address you're going to
on another network. It also can perform some "firewall" or security
functions as well as perform address translation so you can use any IP
addressing scheme you'd like on your local, home network.). If you've got
a big house, or you want to work out by the pool, you'll need a signal booster
or wireless bridge or stand alone access point as well. The signal booster
does just what it says, "boosts" the signal to extend the range of the wireless
network, the bridge "bridges" the open "air" between your Ethernet device and
the wireless LAN and a second access point will link to your
gateway/router/access point to bring even more devices and systems into your
wireless network. Adapters of course, are the cards that you'll put in
each PC (or even PDA) to access the network.
We strongly recommend that you choose your gateway/router/access
point, stand alone access point/wireless bridge, booster and adapters from the
same manufacturer - it will save you time, headaches and "finger pointing" if
and when you have to call tech support with a problem.
-
Your PCs
- Remember that each PC must have a wireless adapter and that you are
going to have to configure each PC to operate in that network - setting up file
sharing, printer sharing and more! Microsoft's Web site has
helpful information. We've included the link to their Broadband Networking
page to get you started
Microsoft's Broadband Networking Page. We've also included the
network area of Apple's OS X operating system to help Mac users understand more
about networking and OS X
MAC OS X Networking.
Additionally, many of the manufacturers of the equipment (such as Linksys) have
guides to help you in planning and implementing your network based on their
technology. Make sure you take the time to at least browse through
before you make your purchases (save yourself hassles and shipping and
driving costs!). And finally, make sure your PCs are ready to network.
Do they have enough memory? Hard drive space? CPU power? If
not, you'll be disappointed, and it won't be a "network" problem at all!

So, ready to go? Check out our review of manufacturers
of wireless networks below.

If you just want to see what's out there, you can jump to our
Wireless Networking Equipment
matrix for all of the information. As always, we've picked our favorites
from each manufacturer - in this area, we've picked a favorite adapter and
access point as well. You can identify those devices by the
ย
symbol.
Additionally, we've priced out, for each vendor
a 4 PC, 1 DSL/Cable gateway router/access point solution that includes 2
notebook PCs and 2 desktop PCs - 802.11g (54Mbps). You can see the results
in the pricing section for each vendor below. We used "online" pricing and
have used "mid-point" pricing, averaging out the prices from a number of
retailers.

Wi-Fi Network Equipment Review
Wireless Home Networks*
(Rankings - best, 5 symbols,
worst, 1 symbol)
|
Company |
Best For* |
Simple Start-Up |
Cost |
Time Savings |
Ease of Use |
Works With |
Support |
Features |
Overall Rating |
|
3Com |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp1/2+ |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Actiontec |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp1/2+ |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
AirLink+ |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
Allied
Telesis |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%% |
|
Apple |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
pp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
ASUS |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY+ |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Belkin |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2+ |
pppp1/2 |
iii1/2+ |
%%%%+ |
|
Best Data |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Black Box
|
RP |
นนนน |
$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%+ |
|
Bountiful
WiFi |
RP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYY1/2
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Buffalo Tech.
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY1/2 |
pppp1/2 |
iiii |
%%%%+ |
|
Cisco Systems |
P |
นนน |
$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@ |
YYYY1/2+ |
pppp1/2 |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
CNet |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Connect Gear |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
CP Tech. |
ARP |
นนน1/2 |
Inc. |
นนนน
|
@@@1/2 |
YYY |
ppp |
iiii |
Inc. |
|
Creative |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp |
iii+ |
%%%+ |
|
Dell |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%% |
|
Diamond Multimedia |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Digi |
ARP |
นนน1/2 |
$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp+ |
iii |
%%% |
|
D-Link |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY1/2 |
ppp1/2 |
iiii1/2 |
%%%%+ |
|
Dynamode
|
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
pp
|
iii1/2 |
Inc. |
|
Edimax |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Encore
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
GigaFast
|
ARP |
นนนน |
Inc. |
นนนนน
|
@@@@
|
YYYY
|
ppp1/2
|
iii1/2 |
Inc. |
|
Hawking Tech.
|
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
IO Gear |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2+ |
|
JAHT |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY1/2 |
ppp |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Kensington |
ARP |
นนนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@@ |
YYYYY |
pppp |
iii |
%%%% |
|
Kodak |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp |
iii |
%%%1/2 |
|
Linksys |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppppp |
iiii1/2 |
%%%%1/2 |
|
Macsense |
ARP |
นนน1/2 |
$$$ |
นนนน
|
@@@1/2 |
YYYY1/2 |
ppp |
iii1/2 |
%%%+ |
|
Micro-Star |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2+ |
%%%1/2+ |
|
Motorola |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$ |
นนนนน |
@@@@ |
YYYY |
pppp1/2 |
iiii1/2 |
%%%%1/2 |
|
NetGear |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYYY |
ppp |
iiii |
%%%% |
|
NewSoft |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii1/2 |
%%%1/2 |
|
Okion |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
ppp1/2 |
iii+ |
%%%+ |
|
Pinnacle Systems |
ARP |
นนนน |
$$$1/2 |
นนนนน
|
@@@@ |
YYY |
pppp1/2 |
| |